Perry County Auditors’ Complaint – DISMISSED

Today, Judge Zanic issued his decision on Sheriff Nace’s Preliminary Objections filed against the Perry County Auditors’ Complaint. A copy of the Order can be obtained here. A copy of the Decision can he obtained here.

The Order simply states, “AND NOW, this 8th day of September, 2014, the Preliminary Objection of Defendant in the nature of a demurrer is SUSTAINED and Plaintiffs’ Complaint is DISMISSED.”

The Decision reviews several of the legal issues involved and declares,

In the case at bar, we have determined that the Complaint is legally insufficient, and as such, a dismissal is required. The Auditors have failed to overcome the demurrer of the Sheriff for two clear and distinct reasons. First, the Complaint improperly seeks to increase the statutory authority of the Perry County Auditors by alleging that auditors in this Commonwealth have the duty to obtain information that was never intended by the statutory language of 16 P.S. §1721 or 16 P.S. §1724. Second, the Complaint does not make any allegation that the Sheriff’s actions have caused the Auditors to fail in performing their statutory duty to audit.

The Decision goes on to state,

Thus, the Complaint appears to be nothing more than a fishing expedition for information unrelated to the Plaintiffs’ statutory duty to audit.



9 thoughts on “Perry County Auditors’ Complaint – DISMISSED

  1. Yeah, that is pretty blunt from a judge. Based on that are you going to seek reimbursement of legal expenses incurred for the good sheriff?


    1. The taxpayers of Perry County will foot the bill for all parties involved… UNLESS the Auditors could be held personally liable for expenses for wasting the court’s time.


  2. Thank you for nipping this off at the bud. As your aware, the New York Journal, last year posted New York gun permit owners names and addresses in their newspaper. If this case would have went the other way there`s no telling what they would have done with the list.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s