Loose Lips Sink Ships…and Closed Ones Could Land You in Hot Water with the Pennsylvania Game Commission

Yesterday, Representative Keller introduced a bill into the Pennsylvania House of Representatives, that would repeal the unconstitutional provision found in the game code which makes it unlawful for a hunter to refuse to answer any pertinent question pertaining to the killing or wounding of any game or wildlife killed or wounded, or the disposition of the entire carcass or any part thereof.

game commission

Currently, in Pennsylvania, it is a crime to invoke your Fifth Amendment rights against a Game Commission Officer in relation to the killing and wounding of any game or wildlife or the disposition of a carcass or any part of a carcass. Jack Coble spent thousands of dollars to fight against this unconstitutional provision in order to obtain relief as applied to him.

As I’ve reported previously, Game Commission Officers (GCO) will be utilizing body cameras in future encounters. As such, an individual needs to be conscious that any information they give to a GCO will likely be used against them. This is true even if there is no camera involved.

Interactions with WCO, GCO or WLCO should be treated in the same manner as an interaction with the police. You, as an individual, still retain your Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures and your Fifth Amendment right to not incriminate yourself. As such, you should not consent to any searches, no matter what the officer offers or threatens nor should you make any statements against your self-interest.

If you have found yourself having an interaction with a GCO and were issued a citation, give us a call to discuss your options. It is not uncommon for hunters to sign a citation only to find out their license has been revoked for the next several years. The best way to prevail in challenging a citation is to give the GCO nothing to use against you.

What should you do in order to help make this bill a law? Tell your state representative to support H.B. 455 and help push to remove this unconstitutional provision from Pennsylvania’s game code!

Who is my representative?

As always, if you found this blog post helpful, share it on Facebook or Twitter by using the buttons below, or forward it to a friend! Be sure to like Prince Law Offices and Firearms Industry Consulting Group on Facebook by using the buttons the right!

4 thoughts on “Loose Lips Sink Ships…and Closed Ones Could Land You in Hot Water with the Pennsylvania Game Commission

  1. Several years ago,my husband was sitting in a tree stand on a friend’s property. Unbenonst to him there was a Piece of a salt block from the previous winter nearby. The game commission showed up (they were looking specically for a neighbor). Long story, short, they revoked my husband”s license for a year because he was “hunting above bait”, even though he completely cooperated. The sad part is, my husband is the most honest person you’d ever meet. I think talking to those officers was an example of a good person trying to help who eventually grts screwed.


    1. Unfortunately, it’s not an uncommon situation.

      The Game Commission is notoriously out of control and until people start pushing back in a legal context, its likely to remain that way.


  2. The secret to preventing the game commission from trespassing on private property is to adequately post the property as “No Trespassing.” The game commission seems to be able to trespass on any property unless it is clearly marked. My friend was issued a citation for nearly the same reason as the victim above. He,however, is as county judge and asked the game commission person directly how he was able to trespass on private property and arrest someone. The game commission person explained to my friend, the judge, the technicalities that unfairly benefit the game commission. His property is now posted.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s