Hunting Violation? Think Twice Before Pleading Guilty…

Hunting license revocation season is upon us. I’ve been contacted by a number of individuals in the last several weeks regarding letters they’ve received from the Pennsylvania Game Commission stating that their hunting licenses have been revoked for the two years or more.

revocation

As I’ve stated in the past and continue to maintain, when you are cited for a hunting violation, DO NOT plead guilty immediately. Seek out the advice of legal counsel. Many individuals are under the impression that by simply pleading guilty they will only be responsible for the fine that is attached. Often times, the officer issuing the citation even leads the person to believe that.

Unfortunately, more often than not, an individual will plead guilty, pay the fine and then receive a revocation letter in the mail. These letters are usually sent several months later and by then it is too late to attempt to reopen the guilty plea. As a result, the only option is to request a hearing in front of the Game Commission.

These hearings are conducted in front of a Game Commission Hearing Officer. The Game Commission’s case is presented by the Game Commission Officer. The individual is allowed to cross examine the officer and then present evidence and testimony of their own. The problem for the individual is they’ve already plead guilty to the citation, so there is no disputing they are guilty. The hearing only allows for the individual to present a case as to mitigating or extenuating circumstances for which the Game Commission may take into consideration in reviewing its decision to revoke.

The hearing officer makes a recommendation to the Game Commission itself and the Game Commission issues a final determination. The Game Commission is under no obligation to accept the hearing officer’s recommendation.

pa_game_commission_fall

What does this mean for you? Several things. First, remember your constitutional right to remain silent. As I previously blogged, the Wildlife Conservation Officers are now able to utilize recording devices in the field. Second, do not make statements without legal counsel present. That includes appearing at a Game Commission office to answer questions in circumstances where you did nothing wrong! Third, if you receive a citation, contact a lawyer immediately. There is an opportunity to fight the citation at the Magisterial District Court level and deal with the issue quickly. Fourth, if you have received a letter stating your license was revoked, contact a lawyer to represent you at the hearing you are entitled to at the Game Commission.

Have you been cited for a hunting violation or know someone who has? Be sure to share this article with your friends and family who hunt. The more informed the hunter is, the less likely they are to have their rights violated. You can share by using the buttons below!

Had a negative experience with the Game Commission? Be sure to leave a comment below!

6 thoughts on “Hunting Violation? Think Twice Before Pleading Guilty…

  1. Important information to heed. I thought it was cheaper and easier to pay a fine than to fight a charge even though I knew I didn’t commit it, and the officer did tell me if I paid the fine everything would go away. Unfortunately 4 years later when applying for a permit for something else I found out I had a “record” because I plead guilty by paying the fine and was being denied my permit. I retained Attorney Joshua Prince to straighten out the permit issue and later after 5 years expired I again retained Attorney Prince to have my record expunged so this bogus charge could no longer be used against me. Had I not spoken to the Game Commission Officers without a lawyer present, the initial charges most likely would have never occurred. A valuable lessen learned the hard way.

    Like

  2. I have three questions regarding the PA GC’s compliance with the Fourth Amendment. I understand Bryan Cutler was successful in getting bill 181 passed which restrained the PAGC’s lawful activity with respect to vehicular searches. But how are terms like “reasonable”, and “suspicion” defined? Also, shouldn’t the Fourth Amendment prevent GCO’s from entering private and posted land? Are they permitted to do so?

    Like

  3. Hi, this year I was cited by the game commission for not reporting a accidental kill, 1 horn on the deer was slightly broke off and didn’t meet the 1inch rule. The warden told me over the phone before he came to talk to me that he wasn’t going to take my hunting license or any property just give me a small fine, when he arrived at my home I was straight forward and told him I didn’t know that a piece broken off was not legal to count. I tagged and reported the deer as I do every year and did everything by the books, still he gave me a $1,000 dollar fine for unlawful killing/taking of big game. A month later I received a letter in the mail that my license was revoked/suspended for 4 years.

    Like

  4. Today I was cited by pa game commission for having a primer in my inline rifle and I was in my atv as I was pulling in my driveway.he said it would be between 150.00 or more what can I do. Please email me with some information…dan stephenson

    Like

  5. I was charged over heresay. Rob of bait barrel and bows, heard it from someone who heard it from someone else, that I killed a turkey. Rob assumed it was a wild turkey and made a false report which lead to charges. Although the person I got turkey from told and showed the warden we had gotten the turkey from him, I was still charged. They claimed they tested the turkey and they didn’t. They also said they couldn’t prove it was a wild turkey. My lawyer at the time didn’t do his job neither. It was suppose to get pushed to court of common pleas. The warden said I wouldn’t face any hunting privileges taken away also the majistrate said the same. I learned when I went to get my hunting license that it wassuspended. The game commissioners never sent me a court notice that they supposedly suspended it. I was waiting on court of common pleas hearing. Never received that. I had to learn by getting shocked when I went for my hunting license. Now somehow more time was randomly added on and I don’t have any other violations. I just wrote a letter to try to find out what the hello is going on. My lawyer will not return any of my calls and failed to do his job. There was no circumstances to even charge me based off of heresay. I live in the country no neighbors. Everyone knew I had a turkey, chickens goats pigs and rabbits. I feel as if I was charged falsely and now paying the price. My kids are getting older by the time I get it back they will be old enough not to go hunting anymore. Kids these days don’t go outside anymore. It’s electronics. Mine I try to teach to live on survival of hunting, fishing, and self sustaining their survival. Now it’s taken away. My daughter will be 18 and gone by the time it is back. My son he will be almost 18. I’m being punished for killing my own turkey for food.

    Like

  6. This is excellent advice. I was cited in 2020 and lost my license for a year. Sure. PGC offers a hearing, but only AFTER they’ve decided to suspend your license.

    Like

Leave a Reply to L.M. Freeman Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s