PA Supreme Court Refuses To Hold That Political Parties Are Above The Law

As our viewers are aware, back in September and in a case of first impression, Attorney Andrew Teitelman and Chief Counsel Joshua Prince secured a monumental victory from the Commonwealth Court in Casper, et al. v. Bucks County Republican Party, et al., where the court affirmed, contrary to the arguments put forth by the Republican Party of Pennsylvania and the Bucks County GOP, that political parties are not above the law and must comply with their bylaws, in addition to, Pennsylvania’s Nonprofit Corporation/Association and Election laws.

Boiled down to its most simplistic terms, the Commonwealth Court held that while the courts do not have jurisdiction to decide intra-party political disputes, contrary to the Bucks County Court of Common Pleas’ holding, the courts do have jurisdiction to address violations by a political party of its bylaws, as well as, the Commonwealth’s nonprofit and election laws. Disgruntled with that decision, the PaGOP and Bucks County GOP petitioned for allocatur with the PA Supreme Court, which is a request that the Court hear the case and reverse the decision below. Today, the Court explicitly denied that request; thereby, returning this case to the Bucks County Court of Common Pleas.

Please join us in congratulating Andy and Josh on an unparalleled trackrecord of success before the Commonwealth Court (and other courts throughout this Commonwealth) in arguing the law and constitution over politics!

One thought on “PA Supreme Court Refuses To Hold That Political Parties Are Above The Law

Leave a comment